# He Was a Good Man

He Was a Good Man / Until He Wasn't is a two-panel comparison meme pairing a character's wholesome image with a villainous counterpart, often sold as a parody of true-crime documentary intros. Redditor submissions on r/SpidermanPS4 and r/memes seeded the format in early 2021, and by May 2021 r/dankmemes users were running it with Rick Astley and other pop-culture bait-and-switches.

## Origin
The earliest known example appeared on r/SpidermanPS4 on January 6, 2021, in a submission titled "My spin on the format," which collected around 7,700 upvotes[1]. A month later, on February 7, 2021, a submission titled "Who's a good boi..." on r/memes reached about 92,300 upvotes and introduced the template to a wider Reddit audience[2]. Know Your Meme catalogued both posts as the format's documented starting points[3].

- **Platform:** Reddit (r/SpidermanPS4) / Reddit r/memes and r/dankmemes (viral spread)
- **Creator:** Unknown
- **Date:** 2021

## Overview
Writers line up two panels side by side. On the left, a character looks kind, heroic, or ordinary; on the right, the same character appears sinister, hostile, or evil[1]. Posters set up the contrast in two ways. One approach uses two genuinely different pictures of the same subject, grabbing screenshots from separate scenes or life stages[2]. The other approach reuses the exact same image but inverts its colors, turning a friendly portrait into a glowing, demonic negative[3].

Many examples open with the caption "Murder Documentaries Be Like," a parody of how true-crime shows cut from a victim's cheerful family photo to shadowy reenactments of their killer[3]. Punchlines usually subvert the setup by pairing a benign subject such as a pet dog, a children's cartoon hero, or Rick Astley with an exaggerated "evil" version in the second panel[2][6]. The humor comes from the deadpan pretense that the inverted-color reveal exposes a hidden dark side.

## How to Use
Pick a single character and place two versions of them in a left-right layout. Caption the left panel "He was a good man" and the right panel "Until he wasn't," or prefix the whole image with "Murder Documentaries Be Like." For the villain half, swap in a different scene showing the character as sinister, or run the original photo through a color-inversion filter so the subject looks demonic[3]. The common convention is to pick a subject associated with innocence or comfort, since the contrast makes the joke land harder[6].

## Frequently Asked Questions
### What is He Was a Good Man?
He Was a Good Man / Until He Wasn't is a two-panel comparison template pairing a character's wholesome image with a villainous version of the same subject[3].

### Where did He Was a Good Man come from?
The earliest known example was posted on r/SpidermanPS4 on January 6, 2021, as a submission titled "My spin on the format," which gained around 7,700 upvotes[1].

### What does He Was a Good Man mean?
It parodies how true-crime documentaries pivot from a victim's cheerful photo to shadowy reenactments of their killer, which is why many examples carry the prefix caption "Murder Documentaries Be Like"[3].

### How do you use He Was a Good Man?
Posters pair two panels of the same character, one wholesome and one villainous, either by swapping to a different picture or by inverting the colors of the original image[2][3].

### Is He Was a Good Man still popular?
Known popular examples cluster in May 2021 across r/memes and r/dankmemes, including bojida_ivanov's Rick Astley edition with about 16,000 upvotes[6].

## References
1. [https://www.reddit.com/r/SpidermanPS4/comments/kra6xm/my_spin_on_the_format/](<https://www.reddit.com/r/SpidermanPS4/comments/kra6xm/my_spin_on_the_format/>)
2. [https://www.reddit.com/r/memes/comments/leozbw/whos_a_good_boi/](<https://www.reddit.com/r/memes/comments/leozbw/whos_a_good_boi/>)
3. [https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/he-was-a-good-man-until-he-wasnt](<https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/he-was-a-good-man-until-he-wasnt>)
4. [https://www.reddit.com/r/memes/comments/n9wre3/yeah_no_shit/](<https://www.reddit.com/r/memes/comments/n9wre3/yeah_no_shit/>)
5. [https://www.reddit.com/r/dankmemes/comments/nbazn5/someone_stop_him/](<https://www.reddit.com/r/dankmemes/comments/nbazn5/someone_stop_him/>)
6. [https://www.reddit.com/r/dankmemes/comments/nahk5j/rick_astley_edition/](<https://www.reddit.com/r/dankmemes/comments/nahk5j/rick_astley_edition/>)

---
Source: https://meme.com/memes/he-was-a-good-man-until-he-wasnt
Published by meme.com — The Internet Meme Library