# Mmm Whatcha Say
"Mmm Whatcha Say" is a video editing meme where dramatic shooting scenes from TV shows and movies are set to Imogen Heap's 2005 song "Hide and Seek," specifically the lyric "mmm whatcha say." The format originated from a 2007 *Saturday Night Live* Digital Short called "The Shooting," which itself parodied a scene from the season two finale of *The O.C.* The meme became a YouTube staple throughout the late 2000s and 2010s, with creators applying the formula to death scenes from *300*, *Degrassi*, *Game of Thrones*, and dozens of other properties.
## Origin
The source material is the season two finale of *The O.C.*, titled "The Dearly Beloved," which aired on May 19, 2005[3]. In the climactic scene, Marissa (Mischa Barton) watches Ryan (Ben McKenzie) fight with Trey. When Trey begins choking Ryan, Marissa shoots him in the back. The moment the gun fires, "Hide and Seek" kicks in over long dramatic shots of the characters' faces[3]. The scene played it completely straight, but the combination of teen soap opera drama and Heap's haunting, heavily processed vocals struck many viewers as unintentionally funny.
The meme itself was born on April 14, 2007, when *Saturday Night Live* aired a Digital Short titled "The Shooting"[3]. The sketch opens with Bill Hader writing a letter to his sister (giving the meme its alternate name "Dear Sister"), before he gets unexpectedly shot[2]. From there, every new character who enters the scene immediately gets shot too, with "Hide and Seek" restarting at "mmm whatcha say" after each gunshot[3]. The sketch turned *The O.C.*'s sincere melodrama into pure absurdist comedy through sheer repetition. A copy of the sketch was uploaded to eBaum's World on December 12, 2009, where it picked up over 290,000 views[3].
- **Platform:** *The O.C.* (source scene), *Saturday Night Live* (parody sketch), YouTube (viral spread)
- **Creator:** Bill Hader (performer), The Lonely Island (SNL Digital Short creators), Imogen Heap (songwriter)
- **Date:** 2007
## Overview
The meme follows a simple formula: take a scene where someone gets shot or dramatically dies, cut to slow motion at the moment of impact, and drop in Imogen Heap's "Hide and Seek" right at the bridge where she sings "mmm whatcha say." The humor comes from the absurd tonal mismatch between violent content and the song's earnest, melancholy vocals, filtered through layers of digital harmonizer effects[1]. The format works because the song hits instantly. That "mmm whatcha say" vocal line, produced using a DigiTech Vocalist Workstation harmonizer that gives it an otherworldly quality, is one of the most recognizable musical moments of the 2000s[1].
Most versions follow the SNL sketch's escalation structure: one person gets shot, then another, then another, with "Hide and Seek" restarting each time[2]. The repetition is the joke.
## How It Spread
The parody format caught on almost immediately. Just four days after the SNL sketch aired, on April 18, 2007, YouTuber tubekatt uploaded "Dear Persian," which applied the formula to the famous "This is Sparta" kicking scene from *300*[3]. That video racked up over 2.5 million views, making it one of the biggest early examples of the format.
The template proved endlessly adaptable. On June 8, 2008, YouTuber "but really, no" uploaded "Jimmy Gets Shot Dear Sister Style," featuring the *Degrassi* scene where Drake's character Jimmy gets shot, set to the now-familiar Imogen Heap track[3]. The video pulled in over 1.9 million views. Any scene involving a shooting, stabbing, or dramatic death was fair game.
Imogen Heap's song itself got a massive commercial boost when Jason Derulo sampled the "mmm whatcha say" bridge for his 2009 debut single "Whatcha Say," which Heap co-wrote[1]. That track topped the Billboard Hot 100, introducing the melody to millions who had never seen *The O.C.* or the SNL sketch[1]. The meme and the hit single fed each other: people who knew the Derulo song recognized the sample in meme videos, and meme viewers sought out both the original Heap track and the Derulo version.
The format kept finding new material as prestige TV served up dramatic deaths. On February 18, 2011, YouTuber POPDUST uploaded "Dear Bieber," applying the treatment to a *CSI* episode where Justin Bieber's character gets shot, earning over 105,000 views[3]. By June 2014, the *Game of Thrones* fandom got in on it when YouTuber StarvinLagoon uploaded "Ygritte Death – Mmm Whatcha' Say," which hit 13,000 views in under a week[3].
The song saw yet another wave of cultural attention in 2020 when it was featured in an episode of the Hulu series *Normal People*[1].
## How to Use
The format is straightforward:
1. Find a clip of someone getting shot, killed, or dramatically injured in a TV show or movie
2. At the exact moment of impact, cut to slow motion
3. Drop in Imogen Heap's "Hide and Seek," timed so the "mmm whatcha say" lyric hits right as the scene slows down
4. For extra comedic effect, introduce additional characters who also get shot, restarting the song each time (following the SNL sketch's escalation formula)
## Cultural Impact
"Hide and Seek" sold over 647,000 copies in the United States and earned RIAA gold certification, with the meme playing a significant role in keeping the song in public consciousness long after its 2005 release[1]. NPR placed the song at number 147 on their list of The 200 Greatest Songs By 21st Century Women+[1]. Music critics have noted that Heap rarely gets proper credit for the ripple effects "Hide and Seek" sent through pop music, with The Ringer's Lindsay Zoladz writing that the song was "indebted" to Laurie Anderson's "O Superman" and Daft Punk's *Discovery*[1].
The meme also demonstrated how parody could function as promotion. Jason Derulo's "Whatcha Say," built around a sample of "Hide and Seek" that Heap helped write, debuted at the top of the charts partly because millions of internet users already had the melody lodged in their heads from years of YouTube parodies[1]. Heap performed the original song at the 2017 One Love Manchester benefit concert and on NPR's Tiny Desk Concerts in 2019, both times to audiences who knew it primarily through its meme afterlife[1].
## Fun Facts
- Imogen Heap recorded "Hide and Seek" during a late-night session after her computer lost power, forcing her to use a DigiTech Vocalist Workstation harmonizer. She thought the result was "so self-indulgent" that nobody would enjoy it[1].
- The song is technically a cappella. There are no instruments. Every sound is Heap's voice processed through a keyboard-controlled digital harmonizer[1].
- The music video for "Hide and Seek," directed by Joel Peissig in 2005, was shot in vertical orientation, making it one of the earliest music videos in that format, years before smartphone vertical video became standard[1].
- Bill Hader's letter opening ("Dear Sister...") gave the entire meme genre its alternate name, despite the song itself having nothing to do with sisters[2].
- Stereogum critic Margaret Farrell described the song's vocal effects as making Heap "sound possessed with disquieting misery, bubbling to an overdose where she sounds occasionally alien"[1].
## Frequently Asked Questions
### What is Mmm Whatcha Say?
It's a video meme format where dramatic shooting or death scenes from TV and film are edited with slow motion and Imogen Heap's 2005 song "Hide and Seek," specifically the bridge lyric "mmm whatcha say"[3].
### Where did Mmm Whatcha Say come from?
The format originated from an April 2007 *Saturday Night Live* Digital Short called "The Shooting," starring Bill Hader, which parodied a scene from the 2005 season two finale of *The O.C.*[3].
### What does Mmm Whatcha Say mean?
The phrase itself is a lyric from Imogen Heap's "Hide and Seek," a song about painfully losing someone[1]. In meme context, it signals an absurdly dramatic death or shooting scene played for comedy[4].
### How do you use Mmm Whatcha Say?
Find a clip of someone getting shot or dramatically dying, slow it down at the moment of impact, and overlay "Hide and Seek" timed to the "mmm whatcha say" lyric. Repeat with additional victims for escalation[3].
### Is Mmm Whatcha Say still popular?
The format is a classic that people still reference and recreate, though its peak production period was roughly 2007-2014. "Hide and Seek" itself gained renewed attention after appearing in the 2020 Hulu series *Normal People*[1].
### What song is used in Mmm Whatcha Say videos?
"Hide and Seek" by Imogen Heap, released in 2005. It's an a cappella folktronica ballad that uses a digital harmonizer to create layered vocal effects[1].
### What was the original Mmm Whatcha Say scene?
The source scene is from *The O.C.* season two finale "The Dearly Beloved" (May 19, 2005), where Marissa shoots Trey while "Hide and Seek" plays over slow-motion reaction shots[3].
### Did Jason Derulo sample Mmm Whatcha Say?
Yes. Derulo's 2009 debut single "Whatcha Say" sampled the "mmm whatcha say" bridge from "Hide and Seek," with Heap credited as a co-writer. The song reached number one on the Billboard Hot 100[1].
### What is the SNL Dear Sister sketch?
"The Shooting" was an SNL Digital Short that aired April 14, 2007, featuring Bill Hader writing a letter to his sister before an escalating chain of shootings, each accompanied by "Hide and Seek" restarting[2][3].
### Who wrote Hide and Seek?
Imogen Heap wrote and produced the song. She recorded it using a DigiTech Vocalist Workstation harmonizer after a computer power failure during a late-night studio session[1].
## References
1. [On the Day of His Birth We Recognize Bill Hader's Most Underrated SNL Performance | eBaum's World]()
2. [Mmm Whatcha Say - Know Your Meme]()
3. [Hide and Seek (Imogen Heap song)]()
4. [Mmm Whatcha Say - Urban Dictionary]()
---
Source: https://meme.com/memes/mmm-whatcha-say
Published by meme.com — The Internet Meme Library