# Nazi Pepe Controversy In the summer of 2016, the Hillary Clinton campaign and major news outlets declared Pepe the Frog a white supremacist symbol after Donald Trump Jr. shared a 'Deplorables' meme featuring the cartoon amphibian. The claim, seeded by a Daily Beast article built on interviews with two self-described trolls, snowballed into an Anti-Defamation League hate symbol designation and one of the strangest media episodes of that election cycle. ## Origin The narrative was seeded on May 26, 2016, when The Daily Beast published Olivia Nuzzi's article 'How Pepe the Frog Became a Nazi Trump Supporter and Alt-Right Symbol,' based on interviews with the Twitter accounts @JaredTSwift and @PaulTown_, each described as an 'anonymous white nationalist'[2]. The two claimed to have coordinated a /r9k/ group to make offensive Pepes, including Nazi versions, and push them at journalists as a 'campaign to reclaim Pepe from normies'[2]. Nuzzi's piece framed the character as newly and inherently unacceptable. The political catalyst came four months later. On September 9, 2016, Clinton called half of Trump's supporters a 'basket of deplorables,' and on September 10, Donald Trump Jr. posted a photoshopped Expendables movie poster on Instagram titled 'The Deplorables,' with Pepe grinning between Trump surrogates like Milo Yiannopoulos and Alex Jones[3][4]. Trump ally Roger Stone tweeted the same image the next day[5]. That single image was the trigger that pushed Pepe from a niche 4chan curiosity into the middle of the U.S. presidential race[1]. - **Platform:** 4chan /pol/ and /r9k/ (image creation) / Daily Beast and mainstream news (viral spread) - **Creator:** Unknown - **Date:** 2016 ## Overview The Nazi Pepe Controversy is the summer-and-fall 2016 media panic in which Pepe the Frog, an innocuous cartoon character from Matt Furie's Boy's Club comic, was reclassified as a white nationalist icon. The label came through a chain of events that started with two anonymous Twitter accounts feeding a reporter, escalated with a photoshopped movie poster from Donald Trump Jr., and ended with the Anti-Defamation League adding a cartoon frog to its official hate symbol database[1][6]. What made the story so weird was the mismatch between the claim and the meme itself. Pepe had spent years as a shape-shifting mood board on 4chan and Tumblr, appearing as Batman, Nicki Minaj, a supermarket clerk, or a jack-o-lantern[2]. A subset of /pol/ users had drawn Nazi Pepes, but so had people drawing every other conceivable version. The controversy hardened one fringe use into the definition of the whole character, and then set off a public tug-of-war between Furie, the ADL and 4chan posters over who actually owned him[7][8]. By the end of 2016 the label had stuck in mainstream coverage. The BBC devoted paragraphs of a pre-election explainer to Pepe, Italy's Corriere della Sera ran him next to swastikas under the headline 'Trump e la rana simbolo d'odio' (translated from Italian), and Apple would go on to reject a mobile game specifically for containing Pepe imagery[1]. ## How It Spread On September 11, NBC News ran a story quoting the Southern Poverty Law Center's Heidi Beirich calling Pepe 'a huge favorite white supremacist meme'[3]. Vanity Fair, Talking Points Memo, The Hill, The Atlantic, The Guardian, The Independent and CNN followed within hours with near-identical framings[4][5]. The next day, the official Hillary Clinton campaign blog published 'Donald Trump, Pepe the frog, and white supremacists: an explainer,' which called Pepe 'sinister' and a 'symbol associated with white supremacy'[1]. Subreddits including /r/OutOfTheLoop, /r/4chan and /r/The_Donald spent the following 24 hours mocking the explainer[1]. The pushback started quickly. On September 13, The Daily Dot ran 'Pepe the Frog is not a Nazi, no matter what the alt-right says,' arguing the character 'lacks political affiliation'[6]. On September 14, the Daily Caller published an interview in which @PaulTown_ and @JaredTSwift admitted they had fabricated the basis of the Daily Beast report[1]. Heat Street's Ian Miles Cheong wrote 'No Hillary, Pepe the Frog is Not a Racist Meme' the same day, only for Heat Street to retract the piece five days later after founder Louise Mensch, a Clinton campaign volunteer per WikiLeaks emails, published a counter-apology[1][9]. By September 26 the ADL had formally added Pepe to its hate symbols database, while conceding that 'the majority of uses of Pepe the Frog have been, and continue to be, non-bigoted'[1]. The story kept unrolling through the election. On October 7, Furie's publisher Fantagraphics issued a statement condemning the appropriation and calling out 'myriad copyright violations' of the character[7]. On October 14, the ADL and Furie launched the #SavePepe hashtag campaign to push positive images of the frog[1]. On November 6, the account @bakedalaska tweeted an 'EMERGENCY BROADCAST' calling on MAGA supporters to flood the web with rare Pepes under the tag #RainOfFrogs, which the Daily Dot then covered as evidence Pepe was 'a racist cartoon'[1]. By the day before the vote, the BBC's pre-election alt-right explainer was still working Pepe into its lede[1]. ## How to Use 'Nazi Pepe' isn't a template so much as a talking point. In practice, people invoke the controversy two ways: sincere posters share screenshots of the Clinton campaign explainer or the ADL entry as shorthand for media overreach, while ironic posters keep drawing Pepe in every conceivable non-political costume to argue the character was never one thing. When making the case one way or the other, a common convention is to pair a mainstream 2016 headline with a bland, apolitical Pepe drawing to show the gap between the two. ## Frequently Asked Questions ### What is Nazi Pepe Controversy? It is the 2016 media and political episode in which Pepe the Frog was labeled a white supremacist symbol by the Clinton campaign, mainstream news outlets and eventually the Anti-Defamation League[1]. ### Where did Nazi Pepe Controversy come from? It grew out of a May 2016 Daily Beast article by Olivia Nuzzi based on interviews with two anonymous Twitter accounts who later admitted fabricating their story[2]. ### What does Nazi Pepe Controversy mean? It refers to the claim that Pepe the Frog is inherently a hate symbol, a framing built from a fringe subset of /pol/ images and then generalized to the whole character[3]. ### How do you use Nazi Pepe Controversy? People cite it as a case study in moral panic and media credulity, often by pairing a 2016 mainstream headline with a benign Pepe image to highlight the mismatch[6]. ### Is Nazi Pepe Controversy still popular? The episode is a classic of 2016 election culture-war lore and is still cited whenever the ADL's hate symbol database or media coverage of memes comes up[1]. ### Who first called Pepe a hate symbol? The Daily Beast was first to frame Pepe as a 'Nazi Trump Supporter and Alt-Right Symbol' in Olivia Nuzzi's May 26, 2016 article[2]. ### What was the Deplorables meme? It was a photoshopped Expendables poster posted by Donald Trump Jr. on September 10, 2016 that included Pepe among Trump surrogates, and it triggered the September 11 wave of news stories about the frog[3][4]. ### Did the ADL really list Pepe as a hate symbol? Yes, on September 26, 2016 the ADL added Pepe to its hate symbols database while noting that most uses of the character are non-bigoted and should be judged in context[1]. ### How did Matt Furie respond? Furie condemned the alt-right's use of Pepe, worked with the ADL on the #SavePepe hashtag campaign, and later published a comic showing Pepe in a casket in May 2017[1][7]. ### Were the original 'white nationalists' behind the story real? The two Twitter accounts, @JaredTSwift and @PaulTown_, admitted to the Daily Caller on September 14, 2016 that they had made up the basis of the Daily Beast story as a prank[1]. ## References 1. [https://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/05/26/how-pepe-the-frog-became-a-nazi-trump-supporter-and-alt-right-symbol.html]() 2. [https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2016-election/trump-adviser-son-post-image-trump-s-deplorables-featuring-white-n646431]() 3. [https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2016/09/donald-trump-jr-pepe-nazi-instagram]() 4. [https://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/trump-junior-roger-stone-alt-right-pepe-meme]() 5. [https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/events/nazi-pepe-controversy]() 6. [https://www.dailydot.com/unclick/pepe-the-frog-alt-right-white-supremacist/]() 7. [https://fantagraphics.com/flog/truthaboutpepe/]() 8. [https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/5740]() 9. [https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/59186]() --- Source: https://meme.com/memes/nazi-pepe-controversy Published by meme.com — The Internet Meme Library