# THEN WHO WAS PHONE? THEN WHO WAS PHONE? is a catchphrase lifted from a badly written creepypasta posted to 4chan's /x/ board on March 28th, 2008. The grammatical trainwreck of the final line turned a would-be horror story into one of the earliest canonical examples of accidentally funny creepypasta, spawning years of parody and a whole subgenre of mocked /x/ submissions. ## Origin The original pasta was posted to 4chan's /x/ (paranormal) board on March 28th, 2008[3]. The anonymous story follows a kid sleeping over at a friend's house who receives a threatening phone call telling him to check on his parents. He creeps upstairs, finds his parents in bed asleep, and the story closes on the now-infamous question, 'THEN WHO WAS PHONE?'[1] No named author exists for the pasta, which is normal for anonymous /x/ submissions from that era. The story has been archived and reposted so widely that the broken final line, rather than the plot, became the identifying artifact of the piece on fan wikis documenting bad creepypasta[1]. - **Platform:** 4chan /x/ (origin) / YouTube, forums (spread) - **Creator:** Unknown - **Date:** 2008 ## Overview THEN WHO WAS PHONE? is the punchline of a short creepypasta where a boy at a sleepover gets a prank call warning him to check on his parents, only to discover both parents are already asleep upstairs, which prompts the broken English twist line that gave the meme its name[1]. The joke is entirely in the grammar. The missing article and the mangled syntax collapse the intended horror beat into something closer to a non sequitur, and that failure is the whole point of why people still quote it[2]. The phrase became shorthand on /x/ and nearby boards for creepypasta that is trying very hard to be scary and failing in the funniest way possible[3]. It usually gets deployed in all caps, often as a reply when someone posts an overwrought scary story with a weak final reveal. Related malformed-English meme templates like 'I Accidentally' and 'How Do I Shot Web' sit in the same family of poorly-phrased catchphrases that older 4chan loved to recycle[3]. ## How It Spread Through the rest of 2008 the phrase settled into /x/ as a recurring in-joke, with users spinning off derivative stories using the same bungled twist structure[3]. It jumped off 4chan and into general forum culture, showing up on NeoGAF and Bodybuilding.com threads where posters asked what the line was actually supposed to mean[3]. Yahoo Answers alone collected over 470 confused posts asking for an explanation by March 2013[3]. On July 30th, 2008 YouTuber SCPantera uploaded a dramatic reading of the pasta, which gave the written joke an audio life and helped push it beyond the chan audience[2]. Humor aggregators like Cheezburger and FunnyJunk picked it up during 2009, and reference sites including Urban Dictionary, TV Tropes and the Bad Creepypasta Wiki eventually catalogued it as a canonical example of the bad-creepypasta subgenre[1]. The meme never really died because its appeal is permanent. As long as creepypasta exists, someone will post one with a clumsy twist, and someone else will reply with the phrase[4]. ## Frequently Asked Questions ### What is THEN WHO WAS PHONE?? It's the grammatically broken final line of a 2008 creepypasta that became a catchphrase mocking badly written horror stories on 4chan's /x/ board[1]. ### Where did THEN WHO WAS PHONE? come from? An anonymous user posted the original story to 4chan's /x/ (paranormal) board on March 28th, 2008[3]. ### What does THEN WHO WAS PHONE? mean? In the story, a kid who received a threatening call finds his parents asleep upstairs, so the question is asking who was on the phone, phrased in mangled English that turned the intended scare into a joke[1]. ### How do you use THEN WHO WAS PHONE?? It's typically posted in all caps as a reply to overwrought or clumsily written creepypasta, signaling that the twist landed as unintentional comedy rather than horror[3]. ### Is THEN WHO WAS PHONE? still popular? It's a classic reference inside creepypasta and /x/ circles, catalogued on sites like the Bad Creepypasta Wiki as a defining example of unintentionally funny horror writing[1]. ## References 1. [https://badcreepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/THEN_WHO_WAS_PHONE%3F]() 2. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AKdftmjhMYo]() 3. [https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/then-who-was-phone]() 4. [https://www.dailydot.com/culture/definitive-guide-creepypasta-slender-man/]() --- Source: https://meme.com/memes/then-who-was-phone Published by meme.com — The Internet Meme Library