Alt Left

2015catchphrasedeclining

Alt Left is a loosely defined political label used to describe far-left activists, Antifa groups, and progressive politicians outside mainstream liberal politics. The phrase blew up nationally after President Donald Trump invoked it at his August 2017 Charlottesville press conference.

Overview

Alt Left is a political label used to describe far-left activists, Antifa groups, and progressive politicians who fall outside the mainstream of liberal politics 2. The term functions both as a self-affirming banner adopted by a small pocket of fringe leftist writers and as a pejorative deployed by conservative pundits and, later, President Donald Trump 2. Vanity Fair and The New Republic both treated the phrase as ill-defined and largely rhetorical rather than a coherent political movement 1.

The New Republic argued that the phrase was legitimized in part by red-baiting liberals who feared the rise of a progressive populist movement, and pointed out that alt-left had always been an insult rather than a self-chosen identity 2. Unlike alt-right, which was coined by white supremacists as branding for their own movement, alt-left was invented from outside the groups it described 2. Vanity Fair's coverage focused on the term's use by contrarian liberal writers who criticized fellow leftists for identity politics and Hollywood grandstanding 1.

How It Spread

In March 2017, Vanity Fair published 'Why the Alt-Left Is a Problem,' calling out writers like Berkeley film professor Eileen Jones, whose Jacobin article had attacked Meryl Streep's Golden Globes speech about Trump 1. Conservative figures including Sean Hannity and future White House Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci were already using the phrase to denigrate Trump's opponents 2.

YouTuber Tim Pool posted 'The Rise of the Alt-Left' on April 30, 2017, drawing a distinction between mainstream liberals and what he called fringe groups that 'do not do research' 8. The label crossed into national political vocabulary after Trump's press conference at Trump Tower on August 15, 2017, where he demanded 'What about the alt-left?' when pressed to condemn the neo-Nazis and white supremacists who had marched in Charlottesville, Virginia 2. One of the marchers had killed counter-protester Heather Heyer by driving a car into a crowd of demonstrators days earlier 2.

How to Use This Meme

The label is typically deployed in one of two ways. Conservative commentators use it to lump progressive Democrats, Antifa activists, and any left-wing protester into a single scary category, often as a rhetorical mirror to the alt-right 2. A small pocket of self-identified alt-left writers, mostly clustered around AltLeft.com and adjacent Facebook communities between 2015 and 2016, used it as an affirmative label for anti-political-correctness leftism 7. Urban Dictionary's top definitions frame the alt-left almost entirely as an insult, describing it as anti-feminist and 'the alt-right wearing anarchist and communist clothing' 5.

Cultural Impact

New Republic writer Osita Nwanevu argued that Trump's use of the term was a deliberate false equivalence, and warned that liberal writers who had adopted it earlier were helping to legitimize the framing 2. The controversy over Trump's Charlottesville remarks put the phrase at the center of political coverage across both conservative and liberal outlets for weeks 2. Vanity Fair's earlier critique had focused on how the term was being used within left-of-center media to attack fellow leftists, especially over Hollywood pieties and identity politics 1.

Frequently Asked Questions