Casually Pepper Spray Everything Cop

On November 18, 2011, students at the University of California, Davis held an Occupy protest on the campus quad. They formed a human chain by linking arms and sitting on a paved path. When they refused police orders to leave, Lt. John Pike and another officer walked down the line and sprayed them directly with pepper spray2. Multiple cameras captured the event from different angles.

UC Davis psychology student Louise Macabitas took the photograph that would define the meme. Her low-angle shot captured Pike in mid-stride, head elevated above the crowd, pepper spray silhouetted against the sky3. That image was posted to Reddit on November 19, 2011, one day after the incident7.

By November 20, two Photoshopped versions had already appeared on Reddit. One swapped Pike over Strutting Leo. The second removed Pike from the campus and placed him into John Trumbull's 1819 painting *Declaration of Independence*7. That same afternoon, a Tumblr blog called It Makes No Sense dropped Pike into Georges Seurat's *A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte*, pulling over 2,400 notes in a single day7.

The meme crossed from internet in-joke to mainstream political commentary almost immediately. Coverage appeared in The Guardian, TIME, The Week, NPR, Scientific American, CNN, CBS News, The Wall Street Journal, and The New York Times within the first week alone1245.

USC academic Jennifer Lee wrote a paper analyzing the meme's role in what she termed "slacktivism," arguing that while the Photoshops kept the issue alive in public consciousness, the viral one-sided framing limited critical assessment of the full incident17. Her paper noted that a longer video showing officers warning students before deploying the spray never achieved the same virality as the shorter clips17.

The meme also fed back into physical protest. Students at UC Davis printed out Photoshopped images as posters and carried them to demonstrations at the exact spot where the spraying had occurred, creating a loop where internet mockery and real-world activism reinforced each other1.

Pike's background added another layer. CBS News reported he had previously been honored twice for meritorious service, including a 2006 incident where he decided *against* using pepper spray on a hospital patient threatening colleagues with scissors11. He was also named in a discrimination lawsuit involving an alleged anti-gay slur, which settled for $240,000 in 200811.

The original pepper spray incident happened during a period of escalating conflict between Occupy protesters and campus police across California's university system. UC Davis students had set up tents on the quad on November 17, inspired by Occupy Wall Street and in solidarity with UC Berkeley students who had been struck with batons on November 911. Chancellor Linda Katehi later said the police acted against her orders, which specified no arrests and no use of force8.

The disconnect between the violence of pepper spraying seated students and Pike's relaxed posture is what gave the meme its unique energy. Scientific American's analysis noted that Macabitas's low-angle shot was the one that won out from dozens of photos and videos because it gave Pike's figure a sense of dominance while keeping his face visible and his outward-pointed foot adding motion to the still image3. Every element in the frame told the same story without needing any context.

Within three days, the meme had spawned secondary reactions. On November 21, Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly appeared on Bill O'Reilly's show and described pepper spray as "a food product, essentially"18. O'Reilly defended Pike, saying he didn't think people had "the right to Monday-morning quarterback the police, particularly at a place like UC Davis, which is a fairly liberal campus"18. Kelly's remark generated its own advice animal series on Reddit, using the template "X, Essentially" with captions downplaying human rights abuses7. A Change.org petition launched by Slacktory editor Nick Douglas challenged Kelly to "drink a full dose of pepper spray on national television"7.

Amazon reviewers piled on too. Users flooded the product page for the specific brand of pepper spray canister Pike allegedly used with satirical reviews and uploaded Pepper Spray Cop Photoshop images as "customer photos"7. The fake review campaign was initially prompted by Change.org via Twitter7.

Music tributes followed fast. On November 21, YouTube musician Andrew Lusk uploaded "Pepper Spray Cop's Lament," which CNN later played during a report7. Jimmy Wong posted an acoustic song called "Dear John (The Pepper Spray Song)," and Harry Shearer, voice of Mr. Burns on *The Simpsons*, released "Ballad of Pepper Spray Cop" on SoundCloud7. A Downfall parody showing Hitler reacting to the meme's spread appeared on November 227.

The real-world consequences for Pike were severe. Anonymous hacktivists released his home address, phone number, and salary records, leading to over 10,000 text messages and 17,000 emails7. A UC task force report released in April 2012 found his decision to use pepper spray "not authorized by policy" and "critically flawed," noting "little factual basis supporting Lt. Pike's belief that he was trapped by the protesters"6. The report also found Pike had misused the canister itself, a higher-pressure model designed for use at six feet or more, not point-blank range6. Pike's employment at UC Davis ended on July 31, 20129.

Even Kamran Loghman, one of the men who helped develop pepper spray as a weapon with the FBI in the 1980s, told the New York Times that he had "never seen such an inappropriate and improper use of chemical agents"1.

In September 2012, UC Davis settled with 21 student plaintiffs for $1 million total, paying each $30,00015. Then in October 2013, Pike was awarded $38,059 in workers' compensation after claiming he suffered depression and anxiety from the backlash10. The irony that Pike received comparable compensation to the students he sprayed drew widespread criticism. Attorney Bernie Goldsmith said the settlement "sends a clear message to the next officer nervously facing off with a group of passive, unarmed students: Go on ahead. Brutalize them. You will be well taken care of"14.

In a final twist, it was revealed in 2016 that UC Davis had spent at least $175,000 on consultants to scrub references to the pepper spray incident from Google search results13. A Maryland firm called Nevis & Associates was paid $15,000 per month for six months starting in January 2013, with one goal listed as "eradication of references to the pepper spray incident in search results"16. The effort failed spectacularly. Googling "UC Davis pepper spray" still returned over 117,000 results, and the news of the cover-up attempt generated its own wave of negative press16.