Home›Memes›I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!

Contents

  • Overview
  • Gallery
  • Origin
  • How It Spread
  • How to Use
  • FAQ
  • References
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! — Yellow tub and retail box of I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Original

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!

1981catchphraseclassic

Published November 17, 2026

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! began as a 1981 margarine brand whose over-the-top 1990s commercials, several starring Fabio, and a shelf full of near-identical knockoffs made the full-sentence name a running internet joke about cheap substitutes. By November 2007, Serious Eats was cataloging bootleg brands with imitation names, and in January 2016 Redditors created r/IsItButter specifically to track the look-alikes.

advertising memes catchphrase memes sarcasm memes food memes consumer culture memes

Overview

As an online joke, the brand name doubles as its own punchline: the full sentence already expresses mock surprise, which makes it a reusable caption for anything that looks like a bad substitute. Serious Eats collected store-shelf bootlegs under the headline "Unbelievable! This Is Not Butter!" in a November 2007 roundup, listing imitation tubs with names mimicking the original1. Reddit's r/crappyoffbrands later picked up the thread with user-submitted photos of similar imitation tubs.

In video form, parodies and re-edits of the brand's Fabio-era commercials circulate on YouTube, where fans upload spoofs of the original 1990s spots2. In text, the phrase is used sarcastically in forum replies to point at anything cheap-looking or fake, a usage Urban Dictionary documents as a stand-in label for a substandard copy3.

Gallery

Origin & Background

Platform
Television (1981 commercials) / YouTube and Reddit (online spread)
Date
1981

J.H. Filbert developed the margarine in 1979 and launched it at retail in Washington, D.C. in 1981, with Unilever acquiring the brand in 1986 and expanding distribution abroad4. A string of melodramatic TV commercials through the 1980s and 1990s made the catchphrase familiar to American viewers, with several spots featuring male model Fabio reacting to the spread4. One of those Fabio-era commercials, uploaded to YouTube, is the clip most commonly linked when the phrase is referenced online5.

How It Spread

After the commercials made the brand name instantly recognizable, the catchphrase migrated online as a sarcastic caption and as a label for the near-identical knockoff products the brand attracted. Serious Eats' November 2007 post walked through retailer bootlegs with imitation naming and set a template for the "look at this off-brand margarine" blog post1. Tumblr users added photo parodies under the brand's tag, and 4chan threads reused the catchphrase as a reply to anything resembling a cheap substitute4.

On Reddit, r/crappyoffbrands became a running collection point for off-brand butter tubs, and on January 24, 2016, a dedicated r/IsItButter subreddit was created just for that category of knockoff4. On YouTube, parody edits of the commercials accumulated, with the phrase showing up in machinima and comedic video edits6. Know Your Meme noted roughly 1,600 YouTube results for parodies of the phrase at the time of its writeup4.

Timeline

1979

J.H. Filbert develops the margarine formulation that would become I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!

1981

The product launches at retail in Washington, D.C.

1986

Unilever acquires the brand and begins international distribution.

2007-11

Serious Eats publishes "Unbelievable! This Is Not Butter!", a roundup of store-shelf bootlegs with imitation names.

2016-01-24

Reddit user creates r/IsItButter, a subreddit dedicated solely to margarine knockoffs.

How to Use This Meme

Common usage is to reach for the catchphrase as a sarcastic label for something that looks like a lesser version of the real thing, or to caption a photo of an actual store-shelf knockoff with an imitation name. Video creators often splice the original Fabio ad audio onto unrelated footage for comic effect.

Frequently Asked Questions

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! is a margarine brand launched at retail in 1981, with a full-sentence name that doubles online as a sarcastic catchphrase about cheap substitutes and knockoff products4.

J.H. Filbert developed the product in 1979 and introduced it to retailers in Washington, D.C. in 1981; Unilever acquired the brand in 1986 and expanded it internationally4. The 1990s TV campaign featuring Fabio made the catchphrase household-familiar in the United States5.

Online, the phrase is used sarcastically to flag a product or thing that looks like a weaker copy of the real version, which Urban Dictionary records as a stand-in label for a substandard substitute3.

Posters typically caption a photo of a suspicious-looking knockoff with the phrase, or splice the Fabio commercial audio into parody videos on YouTube2. Collectors of imitation tubs also post them to subreddits like r/crappyoffbrands and r/IsItButter1.

The brand parody and catchphrase function as a classic internet joke that keeps showing up in bootleg roundups and YouTube spoofs rather than a trending format, with r/IsItButter active since 20164.

References (6)

  1. 1
    https://www.seriouseats.com/2007/11/its-not-butterdeal-with-it.html
  2. 2
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZYqS0FxFj8
  3. 3
    https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=I%20Cant%20Believe%20Its%20Not%20Butter
  4. 4
    https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/i-cant-believe-its-not-butter
  5. 5
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xszIaNpYILY
  6. 6
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2d7FORXnfpk

Quick Info

Year
1981
Origin
Television (1981 commercials) / YouTube and Reddit (online spread)
Type
catchphrase
Status
classic

More like this

Black Cat Clapping
Black Cat Clapping
Sean O'Pry Edit
Sean O'Pry Edit
Neegy
Neegy
Randy Marsh vs.
Randy Marsh vs.
Bobs And Vegana
Bobs And Vegana
Samsung Smart Fridges
Samsung Smart Fridges
Wendy's Twitter
Wendy's Twitter
4Chan Party Van
4Chan Party Van
Nyan Cat
Nyan Cat
Minions Memes
Minions Memes
Montgomery Swizzenbocher
Montgomery Swizzenbocher
Sankey Diagram
Sankey Diagram

Tags

catchphrasebrand parodybootlegmargarinecommercialFabio1990sknockoff

Related Memes

PT

private-taxi-for-my-burrito

private taxi for my burrito

TM

the-more-you-know

the more you know

WA

what-a-time-to-be-alive

what a time to be alive

SS

samsung-smart-fridges

samsung smart fridges

M

mcdonalds

mcdonalds

KS

kermit-sipping-tea

kermit sipping tea

Browse MemesTopicsCreatorsTrendingPlayAboutAdvertiseLegalPrivacy

© 2026 meme.com