
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!
Published November 17, 2026
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! began as a 1981 margarine brand whose over-the-top 1990s commercials, several starring Fabio, and a shelf full of near-identical knockoffs made the full-sentence name a running internet joke about cheap substitutes. By November 2007, Serious Eats was cataloging bootleg brands with imitation names, and in January 2016 Redditors created r/IsItButter specifically to track the look-alikes.
Overview
As an online joke, the brand name doubles as its own punchline: the full sentence already expresses mock surprise, which makes it a reusable caption for anything that looks like a bad substitute. Serious Eats collected store-shelf bootlegs under the headline "Unbelievable! This Is Not Butter!" in a November 2007 roundup, listing imitation tubs with names mimicking the original1. Reddit's r/crappyoffbrands later picked up the thread with user-submitted photos of similar imitation tubs.
In video form, parodies and re-edits of the brand's Fabio-era commercials circulate on YouTube, where fans upload spoofs of the original 1990s spots2. In text, the phrase is used sarcastically in forum replies to point at anything cheap-looking or fake, a usage Urban Dictionary documents as a stand-in label for a substandard copy3.
Gallery
Origin & Background
How It Spread
Timeline
1979
J.H. Filbert develops the margarine formulation that would become I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!
1981
The product launches at retail in Washington, D.C.
1986
Unilever acquires the brand and begins international distribution.
2007-11
Serious Eats publishes "Unbelievable! This Is Not Butter!", a roundup of store-shelf bootlegs with imitation names.
2016-01-24
Reddit user creates r/IsItButter, a subreddit dedicated solely to margarine knockoffs.
How to Use This Meme
Common usage is to reach for the catchphrase as a sarcastic label for something that looks like a lesser version of the real thing, or to caption a photo of an actual store-shelf knockoff with an imitation name. Video creators often splice the original Fabio ad audio onto unrelated footage for comic effect.
Frequently Asked Questions
References (6)
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6