
Anthony Fantano's "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy" Review
Published November 22, 2026
Music critic Anthony Fantano reviewed Kanye West's My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy on November 16th, 2010, giving it a light to decent 6 out of 10 despite near-universal critical acclaim. The lukewarm rating turned into one of his most hated videos and a running joke across Kanye and Fantano fandoms for nearly a decade, until Fantano uploaded a redux review in January 2020 that landed on roughly the same score.
Overview
Anthony Fantano, who runs the YouTube channel theneedledrop, praised the production and lyricism on the record but said the album leaned too heavily on Kanye West's public persona, which he felt ambivalent toward2. His final score of a light to decent 6 out of 10 clashed sharply with outlets like Pitchfork, which handed the album a perfect 101, and with a Metacritic aggregate of 94/1005.
The gap between the critical consensus and Fantano's verdict is what gave the video its second life as a fandom joke. Viewers hammered the dislike button, left years of comments demanding a re-review, and Kanye fans treated the 6/10 as a go-to punchline whenever Fantano scored a new release5. The video sits at over 770,000 views with roughly 20,000 dislikes against only 7,000 likes, numbers that are themselves often cited inside the joke5.
Gallery
Origin & Background
How It Spread
Timeline
2010-11-16
Anthony Fantano uploads his original review of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy to YouTube, concluding with a light to decent 6 out of 10.
2010-11-22
Kanye West officially releases My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, which goes on to receive a 10.0 from Pitchfork and a 94 Metacritic score.
2019-05-09
Volksgeist uploads a guest video on Fantano's channel about how MBDTF became popular with indie music fans.
2019-05-10
Dead End Hip Hop posts an analysis of Fantano's original review and the backlash it caused.
2020-01-09
Fantano uploads a redux review for his 2 million subscriber milestone, giving the album a strong 5 to a light 6 out of 10.
How to Use This Meme
Within Fantano's comment sections and Kanye subreddits, fans typically invoke the review by referencing the exact phrasing "light to decent 6," demanding a re-review, or pointing at the dislike-to-like ratio whenever Fantano scores a new rap album. The joke often shows up as a reply to any Fantano score that feels too low, framing him as permanently wrong about MBDTF5.
Frequently Asked Questions
References (6)
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6