Home›Memes›Anthony Fantano's "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy" Review

Contents

  • Overview
  • Gallery
  • Origin
  • How It Spread
  • How to Use
  • FAQ
  • References
Anthony Fantano's "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy" Review — Anthony Fantano reviewing MBDTF album with LIGHT 6 rating graphic overlay

Anthony Fantano's "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy" Review

2010viral videoclassic

Published November 22, 2026

Music critic Anthony Fantano reviewed Kanye West's My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy on November 16th, 2010, giving it a light to decent 6 out of 10 despite near-universal critical acclaim. The lukewarm rating turned into one of his most hated videos and a running joke across Kanye and Fantano fandoms for nearly a decade, until Fantano uploaded a redux review in January 2020 that landed on roughly the same score.

kanye west memes hip hop memes music memes youtube culture memes fandom discourse memes

Overview

Anthony Fantano, who runs the YouTube channel theneedledrop, praised the production and lyricism on the record but said the album leaned too heavily on Kanye West's public persona, which he felt ambivalent toward2. His final score of a light to decent 6 out of 10 clashed sharply with outlets like Pitchfork, which handed the album a perfect 101, and with a Metacritic aggregate of 94/1005.

The gap between the critical consensus and Fantano's verdict is what gave the video its second life as a fandom joke. Viewers hammered the dislike button, left years of comments demanding a re-review, and Kanye fans treated the 6/10 as a go-to punchline whenever Fantano scored a new release5. The video sits at over 770,000 views with roughly 20,000 dislikes against only 7,000 likes, numbers that are themselves often cited inside the joke5.

Gallery

Origin & Background

Platform
YouTube
Creator
Anthony Fantano
Date
2010

Fantano uploaded his review of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy to YouTube on November 16th, 2010, six days before the album's official release on November 22nd25. In the video he worked through the record track by track and concluded with a verbal rating of a "light to decent 6 out of 10," citing his discomfort with how much of the album was built around Kanye's celebrity persona rather than the music itself2.

The score stood out against the wider critical response. Pitchfork writer Ryan Dombal called the record a "blast of surreal pop excess that few artists are capable of creating, or even willing to attempt" in his 10.0 review1, and the album later won three Grammy Awards, including Best Rap Album5. That distance between Fantano's number and everyone else's gave the review its lasting target status.

How It Spread

For most of the 2010s the review was a quiet grudge inside Fantano's audience, with repeated calls for him to revisit the record. The joke got a visible bump in May 2019, when Fantano went on tour and handed his channel over to guest uploaders5. On May 9th, 2019, a video from Volksgeist walked through how MBDTF became a touchstone for indie music fans3, and the next day Dead End Hip Hop uploaded a long discussion of the original review and the backlash it generated4. Both videos were received warmly by Fantano's audience, who used them to replay the old argument.

Fantano returned to the album himself on January 9th, 2020, posting a redux review to mark his 2 million subscriber milestone and the album's tenth anniversary6. He landed on a strong 5 to a light 6 out of 10, barely moving from his original number, and described the record as overrated while still praising the features and production5. Within 48 hours the redux pulled in over 480,000 views, 31,000 likes and 12,000 dislikes, making it one of the most-watched entries in the ongoing bit5.

Timeline

2010-11-16

Anthony Fantano uploads his original review of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy to YouTube, concluding with a light to decent 6 out of 10.

2010-11-22

Kanye West officially releases My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, which goes on to receive a 10.0 from Pitchfork and a 94 Metacritic score.

2019-05-09

Volksgeist uploads a guest video on Fantano's channel about how MBDTF became popular with indie music fans.

2019-05-10

Dead End Hip Hop posts an analysis of Fantano's original review and the backlash it caused.

2020-01-09

Fantano uploads a redux review for his 2 million subscriber milestone, giving the album a strong 5 to a light 6 out of 10.

How to Use This Meme

Within Fantano's comment sections and Kanye subreddits, fans typically invoke the review by referencing the exact phrasing "light to decent 6," demanding a re-review, or pointing at the dislike-to-like ratio whenever Fantano scores a new rap album. The joke often shows up as a reply to any Fantano score that feels too low, framing him as permanently wrong about MBDTF5.

Frequently Asked Questions

It is a 2010 YouTube review by critic Anthony Fantano that gave Kanye West's album a light to decent 6 out of 10, a rating the internet never let him live down2.

Fantano uploaded the video to his channel theneedledrop on November 16th, 2010, six days before Kanye's album was officially released25.

It stands as a running punchline inside Fantano and Kanye fandoms because his 6/10 clashed with a 10.0 from Pitchfork and a 94 Metacritic average15.

Fans typically bring up the "light to decent 6" rating or the 20,000-plus dislikes to mock Fantano whenever he scores a Kanye-adjacent album low5.

The joke stayed alive long enough that Fantano posted a 2020 redux review for his 2 million subscriber milestone, landing on a strong 5 to a light 66.

References (6)

  1. 1
    https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/14880-my-beautiful-dark-twisted-fantasy/
  2. 2
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jo4S2qlQGs0
  3. 3
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O62GrmNIBSk
  4. 4
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkYvWVA33Ck
  5. 5
    https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/anthony-fantanos-my-beautiful-dark-twisted-fantasy-review
  6. 6
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNaT3KazKoE

Quick Info

Year
2010
Origin
YouTube
Type
viral video
Status
classic
Creator
Anthony Fantano

More like this

Bibble Singing
Bibble Singing
3 Orangutans 1 Blender
3 Orangutans 1 Blender
Movie Trailer Analysis
Movie Trailer Analysis
I Used to Pray for Times Like This
I Used to Pray for Times Like This
Napping Kanye
Napping Kanye
Rin Tin Tin Rap Kid
Rin Tin Tin Rap Kid
Trump Derangement Syndrome Tds
Trump Derangement Syndrome Tds
Cat In the Hat Serial Killer Trend
Cat In the Hat Serial Killer Trend
Epic Boobs Girl
Epic Boobs Girl
Creature Breaking Glass Me At Bros Window
Creature Breaking Glass Me At Bros Window
Dog Singing In Chinese Dog Rapping Skai Isyourgod
Dog Singing In Chinese Dog Rapping Skai Isyourgod
Let's See Who This Really Is
Let's See Who This Really Is

Tags

anthony fantanokanye westmusic reviewyoutubetheneedledropmbdtf

Related Memes

TL

the-life-of-pablo

the life of pablo

MT

movie-trailer-analysis

movie trailer analysis

CK

chief-keef-almighty

chief keef almighty

NK

napping-kanye

napping kanye

0S

009-sound-system-background-songs

009 sound system background songs

KW

kanye-west-holding-notepad

kanye west holding notepad

Browse MemesTopicsCreatorsTrendingPlayAboutAdvertiseLegalPrivacy

© 2026 meme.com