Home›Memes›Christ, What An Asshole

Contents

  • Overview
  • Gallery
  • Origin
  • How It Spread
  • FAQ
  • References
Essay-style layout titled about the New Yorker caption contest with two cartoons captioned 'Christ, what an asshole.'

Christ, What An Asshole

2006catchphraseclassic

Published November 19, 2026

Christ, What an Asshole is a caption blogger Charles Lavoie proposed in 2006 as a universal punchline for New Yorker cartoons, arguing it could replace any winning entry in the magazine's weekly caption contest1. The gag spread through Boing Boing, Gawker and Wonkette coverage, and by 2010 Robert Sinclair had extended it to Marmaduke, Family Circus and other newspaper strips3.

catchphrase memes webcomic memes mid 2000s memes snowclone memes dismissal memes

Overview

The joke works by swapping the real caption of a one-panel New Yorker cartoon for the words "Christ, what an asshole," ignoring whatever verbal setup the artist drew and reading the panel as a flat judgment of the main character's behavior1. Since New Yorker panels often depict a smug husband, a boorish dinner guest or a self-important executive, the replacement caption tends to fit the visual gag without any further edit2.

The conceit is that it undercuts the magazine's tradition of literary, carefully worded captions by giving every drawing the same blunt punchline2. Later contributors argued the same substitution works on daily newspaper strips with recurring obnoxious characters, turning Marmaduke, Family Circus and similar comics into one-line roasts of their title characters3. The expression also drifted off the comics page into blog comments as a stock reaction to politicians and public figures acting badly2.

Gallery

Origin & Background

Platform
Blog (Modern Arthur) / Boing Boing (viral spread)
Creator
Charles Lavoie
Date
2006

Blogger Charles Lavoie posted the original piece, "How 'Christ, What an Asshole!' is the Answer to the New Yorker Magazine Caption Contest," on his Modern Arthur blog in early 20061. The post ran a series of New Yorker cartoons with their captions replaced by the phrase, framing each swap as a valid submission to the magazine's reader caption contest1.

The New Yorker caption contest, which the blog targeted, is a weekly feature that invites readers to write captions for an uncaptioned drawing, with editor Bob Mankoff selecting finalists4. Lavoie's bit argued that the winning answer was always the same four words, regardless of which panel ran that week1.

How It Spread

After Lavoie's post, the gag picked up aggregator attention. Boing Boing wrote about recaptioning New Yorker cartoons with the line, and Gawker covered it under the headline "Correct Answer to 'New Yorker' Cartoon Contest Discovered"2. Wonkette also reprinted the Modern Arthur link while reusing the joke on political cartoons2.

On March 31, 2010, Redditor norrsson submitted the catchphrase to r/funny, where the post collected more than 440 points and over 100 comments2. About two weeks later, on April 16, 2010, Boing Boing linked to Robert Sinclair's expanded gallery at RobertSinclair.net, which applied the caption to Marmaduke, Family Circus and other syndicated strips3. Sinclair wrote that he had tested the theory on comics old and new and concluded the substitution worked on "virtually all" of them3.

On June 17, 2012, Ars Technica ran a piece quoting Bob Mankoff on how often readers actually send the phrase to the real caption contest4. Mankoff told the site the exact caption had appeared only 27 times across the first 332 contests, showing up in 23 different weeks, roughly 0.001 percent of submissions4.

Timeline

2006-02-03

Charles Lavoie publishes "How 'Christ, What an Asshole!' is the Answer to the New Yorker Magazine Caption Contest" on his Modern Arthur blog[1].

2010-03-30

Boing Boing posts "Recaptioning New Yorker cartoons with Christ, what an asshole!"[2]

2010-03-31

Redditor norrsson submits the catchphrase to r/funny, where it draws more than 440 points[2].

2010-04-16

Boing Boing links to Robert Sinclair's gallery applying the caption to Marmaduke, Family Circus and other strips[3].

2012-06-17

Ars Technica publishes Bob Mankoff's count: 27 submissions across the first 332 New Yorker caption contests[4].

Frequently Asked Questions

A caption-swap gag that replaces the punchline of a one-panel cartoon, most often from the New Yorker, with the words "Christ, what an asshole"2.

Blogger Charles Lavoie posted the first gallery of recaptioned New Yorker cartoons on his Modern Arthur blog in early 20061.

The caption reads the panel as a judgment of its main character's behavior, arguing the same four words fit any New Yorker drawing1.

People typically take a captionless or captioned comic panel, strip the original dialogue, and paste the phrase underneath as the new punchline3.

The bit is treated as a classic blog-era joke; Ars Technica reported in 2012 that readers had submitted the exact phrase to the real New Yorker contest 27 times across 332 weeks4.

References (4)

  1. 1
    https://web.archive.org/web/20060203045552/http://modernarthur.com/blog/christwhatanasshole.html
  2. 2
    https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/christ-what-an-asshole
  3. 3
    https://www.robertsinclair.net/comic/asshole.html
  4. 4
    https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/06/christ-what-an-asshole-is-only-001-of-new-yorker-caption-contest-subs/

Quick Info

Year
2006
Origin
Blog (Modern Arthur) / Boing Boing (viral spread)
Type
catchphrase
Status
classic
Creator
Charles Lavoie

More like this

Neegy
Neegy
Is X Gonna Have to Choke a Bitch?
Is X Gonna Have to Choke a Bitch?
Bobs And Vegana
Bobs And Vegana
Randy Marsh vs.
Randy Marsh vs.
La Fairs
La Fairs
Pee Is Stored in the Balls
Pee Is Stored in the Balls
6969 Cool Street
6969 Cool Street
Epic Boobs Girl
Epic Boobs Girl
La Peace
La Peace
It's Me, It's Verity
It's Me, It's Verity
Mr. Worldwide
Mr. Worldwide
Good News Everyone!
Good News Everyone!

Tags

catchphrasenew yorkercartoon contestcomic stripsblog meme

Related Memes

IR

im-rick-james-bitch

im rick james bitch

IT

in-this-economy

in this economy

BC

barbara-corcorans-and-for-that-reason-im-out

barbara corcorans and for that reason im out

HS

homophobic-seal

homophobic seal

HG

haters-gonna-hate

haters gonna hate

IX

is-x-gonna-have-to-choke-a-bitch

is x gonna have to choke a bitch

Browse MemesTopicsCreatorsTrendingPlayAboutAdvertiseLegalPrivacy

© 2026 meme.com