He Was a Good Man
Published November 22, 2026
He Was a Good Man / Until He Wasn't is a two-panel comparison meme pairing a character's wholesome image with a villainous counterpart, often sold as a parody of true-crime documentary intros. Redditor submissions on r/SpidermanPS4 and r/memes seeded the format in early 2021, and by May 2021 r/dankmemes users were running it with Rick Astley and other pop-culture bait-and-switches.
Overview
Writers line up two panels side by side. On the left, a character looks kind, heroic, or ordinary; on the right, the same character appears sinister, hostile, or evil1. Posters set up the contrast in two ways. One approach uses two genuinely different pictures of the same subject, grabbing screenshots from separate scenes or life stages2. The other approach reuses the exact same image but inverts its colors, turning a friendly portrait into a glowing, demonic negative3.
Many examples open with the caption "Murder Documentaries Be Like," a parody of how true-crime shows cut from a victim's cheerful family photo to shadowy reenactments of their killer3. Punchlines usually subvert the setup by pairing a benign subject such as a pet dog, a children's cartoon hero, or Rick Astley with an exaggerated "evil" version in the second panel26. The humor comes from the deadpan pretense that the inverted-color reveal exposes a hidden dark side.
Gallery
Origin & Background
How It Spread
Timeline
2021-01-06
The first known version of the format is posted on r/SpidermanPS4 under the title "My spin on the format," gaining around 7,700 upvotes.
2021-02-07
A r/memes submission titled "Who's a good boi..." reaches about 92,300 upvotes, giving the template its first large Reddit audience.
2021-05-10
PotatoBunny9519 posts a r/memes example titled "Yeah no shit" that collects over 48,000 upvotes.
2021-05-12
Yeetmy6meat9's "Someone stop him" and bojida_ivanov's "Rick Astley edition" both land on r/dankmemes, earning about 12,000 and 16,000 upvotes respectively.
How to Use This Meme
Pick a single character and place two versions of them in a left-right layout. Caption the left panel "He was a good man" and the right panel "Until he wasn't," or prefix the whole image with "Murder Documentaries Be Like." For the villain half, swap in a different scene showing the character as sinister, or run the original photo through a color-inversion filter so the subject looks demonic3. The common convention is to pick a subject associated with innocence or comfort, since the contrast makes the joke land harder6.
Frequently Asked Questions
References (6)
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6