Lord of the Rings Elves of Color Hoax — Film still of Arwen and other elves from The Lord of the Rings standing in Rivendell

Lord of the Rings Elves of Color Hoax

2018fake news imagedead

Published November 2, 2026

A fake news graphic claiming Amazon's upcoming Lord of the Rings series would cast non-white elves spread across 4chan and Twitter in early November 2018. Though no such announcement existed, the mock headline fooled thousands of users into posting angry reactions, which The Daily Dot debunked on November 7th, 2018.

hoax memes lord of the rings culture war memes 4chan memes bait and switch memes

Overview

The image pairs a still from Peter Jackson's film trilogy with a fabricated headline reading, "Amazon Studios confirms that their Middle Earth will include Elves of color"1. No such confirmation came from Amazon, and little about the series had been announced when the graphic began circulating1. The point of the bait was to provoke fans who assumed white skin was a required trait for Tolkien's elves3.

Reactions split along predictable lines. Some users treated the fake announcement as a betrayal of childhood favorites, while others pointed out that Tolkien does not actually specify elf skin color in the books and argued the casting choice would be defensible either way13.

Origin & Background

Platform
4chan /tv/ (origin), Twitter (viral spread)
Creator
Unknown
Date
2018

An anonymous poster on 4chan's /tv/ board uploaded the mock article on November 5th, 2018, with a caption mocking anyone who believed the Amazon adaptation would avoid progressive casting2. The thread used a slur-laden boast that readers had been fooled, framing the image itself as the punchline rather than a real leak2. Amazon had not made any casting announcement at that point, and The Daily Dot later confirmed the graphic was fabricated1.

How It Spread

The image jumped from 4chan to Twitter the same day. User @WrathOfMoe posted it on November 5th with the line, "My entire childhood has been ruined by pandering at this point. Not gonna lie, it hurts," picking up more than 140 retweets and 785 likes within three days4. Two days later, @JimSterling retweeted the graphic with lyrics from Linkin Park's "Crawling," collecting over 200 retweets and 1,500 likes in a single day5.

Pushback traveled alongside the outrage. On November 6th, @Stephenspower argued that Peter Jackson had struggled to costume the elves because Tolkien gives no skin or hair color, calling the idea of "black light elves" cool, a post that drew more than 3,200 likes in two days6. The Daily Dot published its debunk on November 7th, noting that almost nothing had been confirmed about the Amazon production and that the graphic was a hoax1.

Timeline

2018-11-05

An anonymous 4chan /tv/ user posts the fake Amazon headline with a caption mocking anyone who believed it[2].

2018-11-05

@WrathOfMoe tweets the image with a complaint about "pandering," one of the earliest viral reposts[4].

2018-11-06

@Stephenspower tweets a defense of hypothetical dark-skinned elves, pointing out Tolkien never specifies skin color[6].

2018-11-07

@JimSterling retweets the hoax with Linkin Park "Crawling" lyrics, pushing it past 1,500 likes in 24 hours[5].

2018-11-07

The Daily Dot publishes a debunk explaining the headline is fabricated and Amazon has confirmed almost nothing[1].

Loading tweet...

Frequently Asked Questions