What is Milk Coke Debate?

Milk Coke Debate is a viral 2019 Twitter argument over a drink that mixes cola with cold dairy milk, largely kicked off by British comedian James Felton claiming it was a Birmingham favorite[2].

Where did Milk Coke Debate come from?

It started on February 28th, 2019 when @bexin2d asked David Allen Green to fact-check a claim by @JimMFelton that milk in Coca-Cola was 'A Brummie Thing'[4], then blew up the next day when Felton posted photos of himself making and drinking it[2].

What does Milk Coke Debate mean?

The term refers to the split Twitter reaction to Milk Coke itself: defenders posting glasses of the beige mixture under #milkcoke and critics reacting with disgust and disbelief that anyone actually drinks it[1].

How do you use Milk Coke Debate?

People typically weigh in by mixing two parts Coke with one part milk in a clear glass, posting a photo tagged #milkcoke, and either defending the drink (often citing Birmingham or Laverne & Shirley's 'Pepsi Milk')[1] or dunking on it with a disgusted reaction[2].

Is Milk Coke Debate still popular?

The main pile-on was a March 2019 moment covered by Us Weekly, PopBuzz, and Delish[3], and Milk Coke has not returned to the same level of viral attention since.

Milk Coke Debate

2019viral tweetclassic

Published September 6, 2026

Milk Coke Debate is a viral Twitter argument from late February and early March 2019 over whether pouring milk into Coca-Cola is a real drink or a crime against beverages. British comedian James Felton insisted Birmingham locals genuinely love it, kicking off a transatlantic pile-on that split food Twitter, pulled in Laverne & Shirley nostalgia, and made #milkcoke one of the odder food trends of the year.

food memes debate memes british memes hashtag memes food trend memes

Overview

The Milk Coke Debate played out mostly on Twitter as a split between defenders posting glasses of the beige mixture under the #milkcoke hashtag and horrified onlookers replying with vomit emoji1. Fans compared it to established soda-and-dairy combinations like the New York Egg Cream and the ice cream float, while critics framed it as a distinctly British eccentricity nobody should copy1.

Along with the two-parts-cola to one-part-milk ratio popularized by comedian James Felton, riffs circulated using condensed milk, whole milk, and non-dairy options like almond or soy, with some drinkers swapping the Coca-Cola for Vimto or Ribena2. Older users cut in to point out the drink was not new at all, sharing childhood names for it like 'Bop' and 'Brown Cow'1.

Origin & Background

Platform

Twitter

Creator

James Felton

Date

2019

The Milk Coke Debate kicked off on February 28th, 2019 when Twitter user @bexin2d asked writer David Allen Green to fact-check a claim she had heard from comedian @JimMFelton that putting milk in Coca-Cola was 'A Brummie Thing'4. The next day, on March 1st, 2019, James Felton answered with a photo sequence of himself preparing and drinking Milk Coke, captioned 'Milk coke is a real thing. Brummies love it. We can all move on from this discussion now, I will be taking no further questions'2. Felton's tweet drew more than 1,000 retweets and 5,600 likes over the following two weeks4.

How It Spread

Felton's post split Twitter into loud camps almost immediately. Detractor @norespawns tried to disown the drink on behalf of the UK, tweeting that Milk Coke was 'not normal British behaviour' and that Felton would 'be given the help he needs'1. Defender @Pommejane replied with a photo of herself sipping the beige mixture and a straightforward 'Team #milkcoke' caption1.

Twitter itself curated a Moments page about the argument on March 1st, treating the pile-on as a proper trending topic rather than a niche reply thread4. Food and entertainment outlets picked it up within days: Us Weekly wrote it up as a social media schism between believers and haters1, PopBuzz walked readers through the recipe and its Birmingham origin claim2, and Delish added it to their food trend coverage3.

A recurring defense pointed to the 1970s sitcom Laverne & Shirley, in which Penny Marshall's character drank 'Pepsi Milk' on screen1, and to the older egg cream tradition, whose 1880s variations included cola in Indonesian drinks like Mega Mendung4. Those callbacks gave supporters an argument that Milk Coke was really lost food history rather than a Brummie prank.

How to Use This Meme

Posts in the Milk Coke Debate format typically mix roughly two parts Coca-Cola to one part cold milk in a clear glass, add a photo of the beige result, and tag it with #milkcoke alongside either a defense (often name-checking Birmingham or Laverne & Shirley) or a straight-up disgusted reaction2.

Frequently Asked Questions

References (4)