Intellectual Dark Web — Montage of Sam Harris, Jordan Peterson, Dave Rubin, and Ben Shapiro portraits side by side.

Intellectual Dark Web

2018catchphrasedeclining

Published November 3, 2026

Intellectual Dark Web, or IDW, is a label coined by mathematician Eric Weinstein for a loose cluster of podcasters, academics and commentators who styled themselves as dissidents against mainstream media and academia on free speech and identity politics1. New York Times editor Bari Weiss profiled the group on May 8, 2018, drawing heavy mockery on Twitter and inspiring a parody Tumblr the same day3.

culture war memes pseudo intellectual memes debate memes podcast memes 2018 memes

Overview

Members commonly listed under IDW include Sam Harris, Eric and Bret Weinstein, Dave Rubin, Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, Ben Shapiro, Christina Hoff Sommers and Claire Lehmann, though the roster was always contested and the group had no formal membership4. Weinstein pitched the name as a half joke, arguing the figures were pushed outside what he called a 'gated institutional narrative' set by universities, legacy media and Hollywood on topics like biology, feminism and race1.

Online, IDW works as both a self-chosen brand and a punchline. Supporters use it earnestly to signal a dissident truth-telling circle, while critics joke that millionaire podcasters with huge audiences can hardly claim to be marginalized3. The main meme output around the label is parody roster art, especially Dungeons and Dragons style alignment charts that slot Peterson, Shapiro, Harris and the Weinstein brothers into good, neutral and chaotic quadrants7.

Origin & Background

Platform
Podcast (Waking Up) / The New York Times (viral spread)
Creator
Eric Weinstein
Date
2018

Eric Weinstein, managing director of Thiel Capital, coined 'Intellectual Dark Web' partly in response to the May 2017 Evergreen State College protests, where his brother Bret Weinstein, a biology professor, was targeted after objecting publicly to a 'Day of Absence' event asking white students and faculty to leave campus1. Bret later left Evergreen with a reported $500,000 settlement alongside his wife Heather Heying1.

The phrase entered public use on January 3, 2018, when Sam Harris released a Waking Up podcast episode titled 'The Intellectual Dark Web' featuring Eric Weinstein and Ben Shapiro5.

How It Spread

On January 30, 2018, Dave Rubin uploaded 'What is The Intellectual Dark Web?' to YouTube, which collected more than 122,000 views and 1,200 comments over the next four months4. The Rebel Wisdom channel followed on February 15 with 'A Glitch in the Matrix,' a video linking Jordan Peterson, the IDW and mainstream press coverage6. Reddit user leocohen99 posted a parody alignment chart captioned 'Intellectual Dark Web' to r/Jordan_Peterson_Memes on March 1, 20187.

Mainstream coverage came quickly. Los Angeles Times columnist Meghan Daum defended the group in a March 16 op-ed arguing it was the best hope against regressive thinking2, and Reason ran a May 3 explainer calling IDW a left-right confederation defying the 'gated institutional narrative'1. Bari Weiss's May 8, 2018 New York Times feature 'Meet the Renegades of the Intellectual Dark Web' profiled Harris, both Weinsteins, Rubin, Rogan, Peterson, Shapiro, Sommers and Lehmann, and also criticized Rubin for giving platforms to Alex Jones, Mike Cernovich, Stefan Molyneux and Milo Yiannopoulos4.

The Weiss piece set off a one-day backlash. The Observer collected the Twitter pile-on under the headline 'NY Times Intellectual Dark Web Story Savaged on Twitter'3, while Steven Pinker and John Podhoretz publicly praised the article4. Twitter curated a Moments page that same day8, and the 'Welcome to My Intellectual Dark Web' Tumblr launched to catalogue jokes about the piece9.

Timeline

2017-05

Evergreen State College protests target biology professor Bret Weinstein, the catalyst his brother Eric later cited for coining the IDW name.

2018-01-03

Sam Harris publishes a Waking Up podcast episode titled 'The Intellectual Dark Web' with Eric Weinstein and Ben Shapiro.

2018-01-30

The Rubin Report posts 'What is The Intellectual Dark Web?' on YouTube.

2018-02-15

Rebel Wisdom uploads 'A Glitch in the Matrix' about Jordan Peterson, the IDW and mainstream media.

2018-03-01

Redditor leocohen99 posts a parody IDW alignment chart to r/Jordan_Peterson_Memes.

2018-03-16

Los Angeles Times columnist Meghan Daum publishes an op-ed defending the IDW.

2018-05-03

Reason publishes 'What Is the Intellectual Dark Web?' profiling the group.

2018-05-08

Bari Weiss's New York Times op-ed 'Meet the Renegades of the Intellectual Dark Web' triggers Twitter backlash, a Twitter Moments page and the launch of the 'Welcome to My Intellectual Dark Web' Tumblr.

Frequently Asked Questions