Three-panel TikTok collage of people discussing the cowboy, samurai, or pirate question.

Cowboy, Samurai, or Pirate

2023catchphraseclassic

Published November 12, 2026

Cowboy, Samurai, or Pirate is a hypothetical dating question TikToker @megitchell popularized in July 2023, suggesting women ask men which of the three they would rather be to spark conversation. The prompt went viral on TikTok before spiking again in December 2023, when a caption-only video by @notcarurosu drew millions of views and sparked X alignment charts asking men to pin their answer on a triangle.

dating memes character archetype memes thought experiment memes gender discourse memes choice dilemma memes

Overview

Cowboy, Samurai, or Pirate works as a pocket-sized personality test that women float at men to see how they respond. The pitch from comedian @megitchell is simple: men will have strong, unprompted opinions on all three, so the question doubles as an icebreaker and a window into taste1. Answers tend to split along stereotypes, with samurai read as disciplined and honor-bound, cowboy as rugged and independent, and pirate as freewheeling or chaotic2.

Typical posts pair the question with a man's reaction, either filmed live or quoted in a caption, and sometimes with a running commentary on what the pick says about him. Boyfriends negotiate caveats, insist on being the captain if they pick pirate, or rank the three by weapons and lifestyle3. By late 2023 the format bled into visual formats like alignment charts, where men self-place among the three archetypes on X4.

Origin & Background

Platform
TikTok (viral spread on TikTok and X)
Creator
Megan Mitchell
Date
2023

On July 23rd, 2023, TikTok user @megitchell posted a short clip offering "girly dating advice": if you don't know how to open a conversation with a guy, ask him whether he would rather be a cowboy, samurai, or pirate, because he will have strong views on all three1. The video climbed past 8 million views over the next five months5.

EBaum's World wrote it up on July 30th, 2023, noting the clip had already pulled in 2.7 million views in two days and that male commenters agreed the opener was high percentage2. Mitchell never explained the methodology behind the pick, leaving readers to run their own theories on what each archetype signals.

How It Spread

Response stitches arrived within days. On July 25th, 2023, TikToker @synthwhoa weighed the three options in a Stitch that passed 300,000 views6. A /r/WouldYouRather poll on July 28th, 2023 put samurai first with more than 900 votes and cowboy second with over 700, suggesting the hypothetical traveled well beyond Mitchell's audience5. On August 22nd, @freshout_the_oven picked up the question for a discussion video that reached 1.1 million views7.

The question spiked again at the end of the year. On December 25th, 2023, TikToker @notcarurosu posted a caption-only version that pulled past 8.3 million views in three days8. X user MingAutocrat screenshotted the clip the same day and racked up more than 36,000 likes while declaring samurai the right answer5. On December 26th, @harrison_fjord turned it into an alignment chart on X asking men to place a dot between the three archetypes, picking up over 6,000 likes in two days4.

On December 27th, the notcarurosu screenshot was reposted to /r/PeterExplainsTheJoke, where it drew more than 7,800 upvotes in a day5. The same day, @dontbebias69 filmed her boyfriend fielding the question, with him landing on samurai only after insisting he would be a pirate captain, for over 600,000 views3.

Timeline

2023-07-23

@megitchell posts the original TikTok offering the three-option question as dating advice[1].

2023-07-25

@synthwhoa Stitches the video and weighs each option for over 300,000 views[6].

2023-07-28

A /r/WouldYouRather poll runs the question, with samurai winning over 900 votes[5].

2023-07-30

EBaum's World writes up the opener as a dating tip for women[2].

2023-08-22

@freshout_the_oven posts a discussion video that reaches 1.1 million views[7].

2023-12-25

@notcarurosu posts a caption version drawing 8.3 million TikTok views in three days[8].

2023-12-26

@harrison_fjord posts a cowboy, samurai, or pirate alignment chart on X[4].

2023-12-27

@dontbebias69 films her boyfriend answering the question for 600,000 views[3].

Frequently Asked Questions