Where Are Her Organs? — Cartoon of an angry pointing critic shouting 'Where are her organs!?' and 'This is terrible anatomy!'

Where Are Her Organs?

2019catchphraseclassic

Published November 11, 2026

Where Are Her Organs?, also known as Ouch, Her Back and Have You Seen a Woman Before?, is a Twitter argument used to criticize artists who draw female characters with exaggerated proportions. It gained real traction in September 2019 around a Marvel Medusa illustration, and by late 2019 it fueled a running debate over fan art of Captain Marvel and anime women.

fandom discourse memes character design memes gender discourse memes fan art memes hornyposting memes

Overview

Where Are Her Organs? is a rhetorical complaint aimed at drawings of women whose anatomy, usually tiny waists paired with very large breasts, could not fit a functional set of lungs or intestines1. Alongside it, posters use Ouch, Her Back and Have You Seen a Woman Before? as interchangeable barbs, each one treating the drawing as a failed life-drawing exercise rather than a stylistic choice1. A typical use shows up in quote tweets or replies to comic and anime fan art, where a single poster lands the line and a thread of supportive replies piles on behind it2.

The argument carries an internal contradiction that critics seized on fast. Readers pointed out that cartoon men in the same comics have forearms thicker than their heads and nobody asks where their organs are, so the complaint reads less like anatomy critique and more like a complaint about sexualized drawings specifically3. That tension is why the line keeps surfacing: half the thread uses it in earnest, and the other half quotes it back to mock the original poster.

Origin & Background

Platform
Twitter
Date
2019

Catalyst event: on September 7th, 2019, Twitter user @SidneyTucker666 posted an illustration of Marvel's Medusa by artists Nacho Arranz and Fran Duque, and the post cleared roughly 1,100 retweets and 4,800 likes1. Replies piled in asking where her organs were and complaining about her back, with one reply from @EatTheRichIero drawing over 460 likes of its own2. YouTuber Shoe0nhead screenshotted a batch of those replies in a thread posted September 9th, 2019, which is the moment the specific wording crystallized as a recognized argument people were having rather than one-off sniping3.

Comments like Where Are Her Organs? and Have You Seen a Woman Before? had been circulating on Twitter since the summer of 2019 against artists drawing exaggerated female figures, and pushback against those comments was already building in parallel1. The Medusa thread is treated as the trend's viral point rather than the invention of the phrase.

Loading tweet...

How It Spread

Counter-tweets started landing almost immediately. On September 9th, 2019, user @_Vs_The_World posted a reply to the discourse that pulled over 1,400 retweets and 7,600 likes across the following eight months4. Ten days later, on September 19th, comic book artist J. Scott Campbell answered a user who had deployed the argument against his work, and his reply gathered more than 5,700 retweets and 34,300 likes5.

The debate flared again on November 7th, 2019, when @DANVERSCOVEN quote tweeted fan art of Captain Marvel by @PabloRomero with the line WHERE THE FUCK ARE HER ORGANS, clearing over 9,400 retweets and 52,200 likes before the tweet came down1. A November 9th response from @nakanodrawing, part of the counter wave, drew over 1,300 retweets and 6,500 likes1. Days later, on November 22nd, 2019, Shoe0nhead posted a video titled THE ANIME TlDDY POLICE that passed 1.6 million views within six months, carrying the debate well past Twitter6.

Timeline

2019-06

Comments like Where Are Her Organs?, Her Poor Back and Have You Seen a Woman Before? start showing up on Twitter against artists drawing exaggerated female figures.

2019-09-07

@SidneyTucker666 posts a Medusa illustration by Nacho Arranz and Fran Duque, triggering the reply thread that became the viral turning point.

2019-09-09

Shoe0nhead screenshots a batch of Where Are Her Organs?-style replies into a thread, and @_Vs_The_World posts an early counter tweet.

2019-09-19

Comic artist J. Scott Campbell publicly answers a user who used the argument on his work, drawing 34,000-plus likes.

2019-11-07

@DANVERSCOVEN quote tweets @PabloRomero's Captain Marvel fan art with the line in all caps, passing 52,000 likes before deletion.

2019-11-22

Shoe0nhead publishes the YouTube video THE ANIME TlDDY POLICE, which clears 1.6 million views in six months.

Loading tweet...

How to Use This Meme

Posters typically quote tweet a piece of fan art and open with the exact line, often in all caps, sometimes stacked with Ouch, Her Back for emphasis. Counter-posters use the same phrase sarcastically under hyper-stylized male characters to point out the double standard, which is now the common convention when the argument resurfaces.

Frequently Asked Questions