
Why Isn't It Possible? Why Not?
Published November 19, 2026
Why Isn't It Possible? Why Not? is a video caption format drawn from the lawyer confession scene in the 2000 film American Psycho, where Patrick Bateman's crimes are brushed off as impossible. Starting in November 2021, TikTok and YouTube users looped the clip under captions about absurd denials, with @true.sigma's homeless-guy version racking up 1.4 million views2.
Overview
Why Isn't It Possible? Why Not? takes a short clip from the final act of American Psycho, where Patrick Bateman phones his lawyer Harold Carnes to confess multiple murders and is met with amused disbelief3. In the loop that got reused as a template, Carnes repeats variations of the question to Bateman while brushing the confession off, giving the audio a rhythm that fits captions about any denied-but-true scenario1.
Typical posts stack an absurd setup text over the clip, usually something the poster claims to have asked an obviously unreachable target, like a homeless person about buying a house or a game character about leaving a town2. The humor sits on the mismatch between Bateman's deadpan question and the ridiculous premise in the caption, which is why a green screen version of the scene traveled further than lip-sync covers using the same audio1.
Origin & Background
How It Spread
Timeline
2000-04-14
American Psycho premieres, containing the lawyer confession scene later used as source material.
2021-11-15
YouTube user rai uploads a green screen template of the scene and a Pokemon edit the same day.
2021-11-17
TikToker @true.sigma posts the homeless-guy caption version, which hits 1.4 million views.
2021-11-17
IFunny user frut reposts @true.sigma's TikTok, pulling 25,700 smiles.
2022-01-14
Instagram account jazzmemes_ posts a caption edit that collects 73,800 views.
How to Use This Meme
Posters typically put a short caption over the green screen clip describing an impossible request made to someone who obviously can't fulfill it, then let Bateman ask the question for them. A common convention is framing the setup as "me asking [subject] why they can't just [action]" where the action is comically out of reach for that subject2.