Home›Memes›Why Isn't It Possible? Why Not?

Contents

  • Overview
  • Gallery
  • Origin
  • How It Spread
  • How to Use
  • FAQ
  • References
Why Isn't It Possible? Why Not? — Close-up of Christian Bale as Patrick Bateman speaking with a pained expression in a scene from American Psycho.

Why Isn't It Possible? Why Not?

2021video captionclassic

Published November 19, 2026

Why Isn't It Possible? Why Not? is a video caption format drawn from the lawyer confession scene in the 2000 film American Psycho, where Patrick Bateman's crimes are brushed off as impossible. Starting in November 2021, TikTok and YouTube users looped the clip under captions about absurd denials, with @true.sigma's homeless-guy version racking up 1.4 million views2.

movie quote memes dialogue edit memes green screen memes tiktok sound trends absurdist humor memes

Overview

Why Isn't It Possible? Why Not? takes a short clip from the final act of American Psycho, where Patrick Bateman phones his lawyer Harold Carnes to confess multiple murders and is met with amused disbelief3. In the loop that got reused as a template, Carnes repeats variations of the question to Bateman while brushing the confession off, giving the audio a rhythm that fits captions about any denied-but-true scenario1.

Typical posts stack an absurd setup text over the clip, usually something the poster claims to have asked an obviously unreachable target, like a homeless person about buying a house or a game character about leaving a town2. The humor sits on the mismatch between Bateman's deadpan question and the ridiculous premise in the caption, which is why a green screen version of the scene traveled further than lip-sync covers using the same audio1.

Origin & Background

Platform
YouTube (template) / TikTok (viral spread)
Date
2021

American Psycho premiered on April 14th, 2000, and the lawyer confession scene appears near the end of the film with Christian Bale playing Bateman and Stephen Bogaert playing the lawyer who waves off the admission3. Mary Harron directed the film from a Bret Easton Ellis novel, so the meme's subject existed for more than two decades before anyone turned the clip into a video caption format.

The template appeared on November 15th, 2021, when YouTube user rai uploaded a green screen cut of the scene for other editors to overlay captions onto1. Rai posted a Pokemon edit of the same clip the same day about trying to leave for Sunyshore City, which gave the format its first joke application4.

How It Spread

The format jumped to TikTok on November 17th, 2021, when @true.sigma captioned the clip "me asking a homeless guy why he can't just buy a house," picking up 1.4 million views and 174,500 likes over the next five months2. Lip-sync covers of the dialogue followed from accounts like @chouffevon and @leonnorfolk the same week, keeping the audio circulating even when the original clip wasn't being reused3.

The TikTok crossed to iFunny that same day, with user frut reposting @true.sigma's video to pull in more than 25,700 smiles3. Instagram picked up the template in early 2022, and on January 14th, 2022, jazzmemes_ ran a video caption version that collected 73,800 views and 5,800 likes over three months3.

Across Reddit, Twitter and YouTube, the clip kept getting reused as one of several American Psycho caption audios floating around in early 20223. Posters treated the Bateman confession alongside the business card scene and the Huey Lewis monologue, with the lawyer scene standing out for being self-contained enough to work over any absurd premise.

Timeline

2000-04-14

American Psycho premieres, containing the lawyer confession scene later used as source material.

2021-11-15

YouTube user rai uploads a green screen template of the scene and a Pokemon edit the same day.

2021-11-17

TikToker @true.sigma posts the homeless-guy caption version, which hits 1.4 million views.

2021-11-17

IFunny user frut reposts @true.sigma's TikTok, pulling 25,700 smiles.

2022-01-14

Instagram account jazzmemes_ posts a caption edit that collects 73,800 views.

TikTok

How to Use This Meme

Posters typically put a short caption over the green screen clip describing an impossible request made to someone who obviously can't fulfill it, then let Bateman ask the question for them. A common convention is framing the setup as "me asking [subject] why they can't just [action]" where the action is comically out of reach for that subject2.

Frequently Asked Questions

It's a video caption meme that loops a clip of Patrick Bateman's lawyer refusing to believe his confession in American Psycho, paired with a text overlay about an absurd denied request3.

The scene is from the 2000 film American Psycho; the meme template was uploaded to YouTube by user rai on November 15th, 20211.

The audio plays as a stand-in for any authority figure brushing off something obvious, so captions use it to joke about asking someone an impossible question2.

Posters usually overlay a "me asking [subject] why they can't just [action]" caption on the green screen clip, letting Bateman's lawyer deliver the dismissal2.

The format held on through early 2022 alongside other American Psycho caption audios on TikTok, Instagram and iFunny3.

References (4)

  1. 1
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gE6AVp-2Jic
  2. 2
    https://www.tiktok.com/@true.sigma/video/7031643882928540934
  3. 3
    https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/why-isnt-it-possible-why-not
  4. 4
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Psycho_(film)

Quick Info

Year
2021
Origin
YouTube (template) / TikTok (viral spread)
Type
video caption
Status
classic

More like this

It's Me, It's Verity
It's Me, It's Verity
Black Cat Clapping
Black Cat Clapping
67 Kid
67 Kid
Fahh
Fahh
Ankha Zone
Ankha Zone
Neegy
Neegy
6969 Cool Street
6969 Cool Street
Epic Boobs Girl
Epic Boobs Girl
La Peace
La Peace
Misery Girl
Misery Girl
Stick Bugged
Stick Bugged
¿Quieres?
¿Quieres?

Tags

american psychotiktokvideo captionpatrick batemanchristian baleyoutube

More TikTok Sound Trends Memes

KG

kawaikute-gomen

kawaikute gomen

DD

ding-dong-eat-it-up

ding dong eat it up

SS

sea-shanty-tiktok

sea shanty tiktok

TT

tiktok-text-to-speech

tiktok text to speech

12

1-2-buckle-my-shoe-3-4-buckle-some-more-5-6-nike-kicks

1 2 buckle my shoe 3 4 buckle some more 5 6 nike kicks

2D

2-days-into-college

2 days into college

View all TikTok Sound Trends memes →

Related Memes

WJ

we-just-got-8-free-pizzas

we just got 8 free pizzas

ST

stings-the-nostrils-in-a-good-way

stings the nostrils in a good way

ON

oh-no-monkey-planet-of-the-apes-oh-no-monkey

oh no monkey planet of the apes oh no monkey

ID

i-didnt-know-there-was-this-much-green-in-the-whole-galaxy

i didnt know there was this much green in the whole galaxy

SI

sir-if-you-have-a-complaint-i-suggest-you-submit-it-through-our-email-system-you-are-done

sir if you have a complaint i suggest you submit it through our email system you are done

YM

you-met-me-at-a-very-chinese-time-in-my-life

you met me at a very chinese time in my life

Browse MemesTopicsCreatorsTrendingPlayAboutAdvertiseLegalPrivacy

© 2026 meme.com