The Truth About Sans
Published November 19, 2026
In February 2016, Game Theory host Matthew Patrick argued in a YouTube video that Sans from Undertale was secretly Ness from Earthbound, and the theory got laughed out of the fandom within weeks. Fans started calling the running joke 'The Truth About Sans' or 'Sans Is Ness,' and by November 2016, SiIvaGunner rips were slotting MatPat's voice clip over songs like 'I Believe I Can Fly' as a punchline about overreaching fan theories.
Overview
The Truth About Sans / Sans Is Ness usually surfaces as a sampled line from MatPat's own narration, cut into a song where its placement makes no sense1. SiIvaGunner, the parody music channel known for deceptive 'high quality rips,' leaned into the gag by weaving Undertale tracks into Earthbound rips and vice versa4. Fans still use the phrase as a punchline whenever someone pushes a thin fan theory.
The joke targets MatPat's reasoning style more than Undertale or Earthbound themselves. Critics said he drew sweeping conclusions from surface details and skipped evidence that cut against the pairing4. A parody Twitter account, Game Theory Rejects, posts mock theories in the same voice, extending the bit well past the original video5.
Gallery
Origin & Background
How It Spread
Timeline
2016-02-09
Matthew Patrick uploads the 'Sans's SECRET Identity!' Game Theory video to YouTube, claiming Sans from Undertale is Ness from Earthbound.
2016-02-09
Toby Fox tweets from @FwugRadiation that he feels embarrassed when fans spotlight his teenage Earthbound Halloween Hack.
2016-11-15
SiIvaGunner fan channel TimmyTurnersGrandDad uploads an 'I Believe I Can Fly' rip that replaces the hook with MatPat saying 'Sans is Ness.'
2017-07
Parody Twitter account Game Theory Rejects passes 26,000 followers posting mock MatPat theories.
How to Use This Meme
Posters typically clip MatPat saying 'Sans is Ness' into unrelated audio, most often a pop or video game track where the line replaces an existing lyric. In text form, fans drop the phrase as a reply to any fan theory that stretches thin evidence into a big reveal.